The Beginning....
I am still not quite sure why I have been wanting to blog about my gelding, Shorty. Maybe it's because I feel like it would be good to keep track of his progress more thoroughly, maybe to share experience and hope to others who struggle with long term/hard to pin point lameness in their horses, maybe it's because I think something like this will help me do him justice if I should ever decide to sell him, or maybe I just need an outlet to talk about the most perfect horse and the most endless struggle. There are a lot of details for this first post since it was in January 2012 when I bought Shorty as my eventing prospect horse.
"Wow, I feel like I could take him to a show next weekend!" That is what I thought after my first test ride on Shorty. This is in spite of him not really doing much for months which was impressive. Well trained, responsive, easy, and uncomplicated to ride. He approached all jumps with ears pricked forward, yet so calm and happy to walk with his head stretched down. Not hot, not lazy, but just right! I hadn't even sold my mare yet, but I knew that once I had, he was probably the horse I would return to buy if he was still available. He had some experience jumping, fox hunting, and had been cross country schooling, but never shown yet. I thought he was great.
That was my first impression of Shorty. He was a gentleman and sweet as can be to be around. Luckily for me, the little red horse at 14.2 1/2 hands high, was still available a couple of weeks later after I sold my mare. Boarding in the city does not allow me to have more than one trusty steed, and so my adventures ended with my barrel racing mare, and began with this 7 y/o chunky red boy because I had a dream of trying eventing!
Shorty in Jan. 2012 - 7 yrs old 14.2 1/2 hh
"Holy cresty neck!" exclaimed someone on my horse forums. The plan was to get to work straight away, but then we hit a snag. The barn PIG! A huge, full grown, black potbellied pig wondered the boarding stable we were at, and it did not take long to find out that Shorty's opinion of it was NOT good. Shorty and I spent the better part of January through the beginning of March just getting used to eachother. I found out that even when nervous, he was a safe boy. He might freeze to look, but no turn, bolt, or buck and the most spook I have ever gotten was a few steps to the side or forward and then done. At first, we rode in the bottom arena where the pig never went, did tons of ground work to establish our relationship, and then finally in March we were ready for our first eventing lesson! At this point we could ride in the main ring and he was spending more time around the pig. Never felt like I could get him 100% focused with the pig in sight, but he proved to be safe.
March 2012 - LAME!
When we began trotting in our first lesson, Shorty was obviously lame! So this is where it all began. All the struggles. He ended up being diagnosed via ultrasound with a front left check ligament tear. It was never an obvious injury - no heat nor swelling. I had even waited a week or so before calling out the vet to see if it resolved - maybe an abscess or something. It was diagnosed with moderate improvement by blocking. Treated with sweating, box rest, hand walking, and even shockwave therapy. After the initial couple months of nothing but rest, I hand walked him religiously and since he was so calm I was cleared to ride him at a walk. Over a span of about 6 months we were back to very light walk, trot, canter work and all seemed well for quite some time!
Late 2012
He presented with the same type lameness as before, again only seen at the trot. I had him re-checked by ultrasound by another vet (different barn at this point) and she had said it was all clear. But we began rehab again to see if he could come back slowly and stay sound this time.
At this point, I had fallen in love with Shorty. We had spent countless hours of bonding time with all the rehab we had done and I was absolutely religious about it. I knew him inside out, and Shorty knew my car and would whinny at me in greeting almost everyday. He proved to be very dependable and a SUPER trail horse. I am not the bravest rider in the world, and he was good for me. I knew he was special, and so I just kept going with him, hoping that we would somehow get through this and continue on our way to the lower levels of eventing! Nine months of rehab later...
Fall of 2013
We were back doing light walk, trot, and canter, but it was weird because he wouldn't hold the canter. A chiropractor was recommended to me to try, and so we did a couple sessions with her and it really seemed to help.
Summer 2014
No complaints really until June of 2014. He was going very nicely in dressage at this point, and we had done some small cross rails here and there as well. It was fun! But that summer I began to realize how slowly but surely he had become lazier, wouldn't stay round in canter transitions, and was hard to get into a real working trot. He was not showing lameness per say, but now I know he was tending to land more on his toes in front, jabbing at the trot, which really is a type of lameness. We had our first dressage show in Nov. 2014 that really showed his pokeyness, and although he did well, I was concerned. We checked saddle fit (went from a wide to medium tree!!!) and we did a couple more chiro adjustments (with a different person) that I thought helped.
Winter 2014
Did not ride as much during the winter months (did not have an indoor arena anymore), but we tried and he would have strange bouts of lameness show up 10-15 minutes into a ride, and that would disappear just as quickly after a walk break. I thought it looked like the right front leg though (last time it was the left), so while it was easy to think his old injury might be coming back to haunt us, I was beginning to think that there was something else causing all of this that was missed even the very first time! We also experienced issues with holding canter again. I had the chiro out, and at this point I was also suspecting arthritis and so I had started him on a joint supplement. We had improvement! Until...
March 2015....here we go again
At the very end of March he comes up head bobbing lame after I witness him running around playing in the pasture (10 minutes straight playing, seriously!). The vet was able to do a lameness exam the next day while he was still pretty lame. With blocking it was suspected he had a bilateral lameness that looked a lot like caudal heel pain. So those daunting thoughts of navicular syndrome were seeping into the mix.... his x-rays were pretty clean which was fantastic to hear, but everyone knows that navicular can be tricky. Could it be soft tissue? Well I thought he went better on softer footing than hard, which points to joint/arthritis. Now that I think about it, he seemed to move great in soft, muddy, soupy footing after rain (I was desperate to ride lol)). We put on a set of bar shoes in front which he responded to GREAT at first. Then when that did not keep him 100% comfortable beyond a couple weeks, we even tried injecting his coffin joints. All this seemed to be pretty well until June 2nd 2015 when we had another lazy and short strided ride. The up and down and up and down was wearing on me.
Second Opinion - giving up
Another vet was recommended to me for a second opinion. This vet admitted that he was a bit stumped. He actually suspected EPM due to some slight neurological signs he saw. Seven long days I awaited test results, where luckily he was negative. But what about him being neuro? Another dead end?
My beautiful horse - what to do? I was getting very restless. I wanted to jump. I wanted to ride. I began taking lessons on other horses and while it wasn't the same, I loved that they could do more than I have been able to do in a long time. It made me happy. So maybe it was time to consider getting him a new home that would only want to use him as a trail horse, and getting me a new horse that could do what I wanted. He had always been fine walking, is a super trail buddy, and would be fine doing some trot and canter here and there. But it was too much work for what I wanted to do, and I could only keep one horse :-/
There was one more thing my vet and farrier wanted to try. We put him in two degree wedge pads with the bar shoes in July. I thought this immediately made him feel better, and I just let him hang out for the rest of the month, hopping on him bareback or saddling up to practice my 2-point at the walk once in a while. The plan was for him to go live with my parents where my mom would try him out on the trails. He is SO wonderful on the trails. I knew she would enjoy him and he would definitely enjoy it!!
Third Opinion
Two days before moving him, I had a vet out who specializes in chiro/acupuncture and has a lot of knowledge in bodywork and biomechanics. I just wanted to make sure I had done everything I could so that he would do great for a leisurely life with my mom. I didn't know what to expect, but since he does improve with keeping adjusted I thought it would be a good idea. I had actually found her website several weeks ago wanting her to come out, but I wasn't sure where to put my money at the time and unfortunately I had to be conservative.
Could it Be?
I had a great experience with the vet when she came. All of my vets and farriers have been wonderful but I think she may have found that "thing" that I suspected has been persisting so long in the shadows. She diagnosed him with neck inflammation/arthritis. I had actually had many people ask about his neck, back, etc., but nobody so far that saw him focused on this type of diagnosis. He did, afterall, present with classic navicular type symptoms! I'm not saying that it couldn't still be part of the issue, but I pray that it is not. I cringe at the thought that he WOULD be navicular for sure if I couldn't help him move more correctly (not toe first). This vet thought that his neck soreness could have been caused by trauma such as falling, slipping, pulling back (which he has set back several times in the past), etc. Sometimes you just never know and many times nobody witnesses these things. The vet immediately saw the same neuro signs that the second vet did and did a more thorough exam. Neck issues like this can absolutely cause neuro signs. But the good thing is, she gave him a very good prognosis, especially since we haven't focused on this type of treatment yet! She has seen horses worse than him turn around. She adjusted his back and pelvis which were not hard fixes, and then ended with acupuncture. Interestingly enough, her exam did not detect any pain in the feet. He has always had great feet! So we either fixed his feet, or his feet issues were completely secondary. She did say that neck horses will generally benefit from having front shoes, and maybe the pad that we added helps support even more, similar to how shoe inserts work for us. I am thinking maybe keep a simple rim pad on him instead of a wedge if we find it is not needed afterall.
Shorty is a wonderful wonderful and special horse. He is so quiet and personality plus! I still do not know if I will get to try low level eventing with him, but it is very possible that he could depending on how he responds to managing his neck issues. Maybe even resolving them! Right now, my focus is just to get him BETTER and see what he can do :)
In my next post I will share his treatment plan and tell about how his first week went!